Template:Unreliable source?: Difference between revisions
Template>SMcCandlish (Use same more tweaked subst code as other templates in this family) |
m (62 revisions imported from alpha:Template:Unreliable_source?) |
||
| (10 intermediate revisions by 8 users not shown) | |||
| Line 1: | Line 1: | ||
{{ | {{ safesubst:<noinclude/>#invoke:Unsubst||date=__DATE__ |$B= | ||
<!--{{Unreliable source?}} begin-->{{Fix | <!--{{Unreliable source?}} begin-->{{Fix | ||
| subst = <includeonly>{{subst: | | subst = <includeonly>{{subst:substcheck}}</includeonly> | ||
| name = {{{name|Unreliable source?}}} | | name = {{{name|Unreliable source?}}} | ||
| link = Wikipedia: | | link = Wikipedia:Reliable sources | ||
| title = The material near this tag may rely on an unreliable source. {{{reason|}}} | | title = The material near this tag {{#if:{{{sure|{{{certain|{{{failed|}}}}}}}}}|relies|may rely}} on an unreliable source. {{{reason|}}} | ||
| text = unreliable source{{# | | text = unreliable source{{#if:{{{sure|{{{certain|{{{failed|}}}}}}}}}||?}} | ||
| date = {{{date|}}} | | date = {{{date|}}} | ||
| cat = [[Category:All articles lacking reliable references]] | | cat = [[Category:All articles lacking reliable references]] | ||
Latest revision as of 14:42, 22 December 2022
Usage
This template is intended to be used when a statement is sourced but it is questionable whether the source used is reliable for supporting the statement. It produces a superscripted notation like the following:
- It was actually written by Francis Bacon.[unreliable source?]
Articles tagged with this template will be categorized into Category:All articles lacking reliable references.
Place this template inline, {{Unreliable source?|date=November 2024}} following the questionable claim (and any punctuation attached to it). The template should be placed outside the reference (<ref> ... </ref>), within the article's text:
- Potentially controversial statement.
<ref>some alleged source for this</ref>{{Unreliable source?|date=November 2024}}Next sentence.
Parameters
The template has the following optional parameters:
- date: should be set to the month and year when the article was tagged. Example:
{{Unreliable source?|date=November 2024}} - reason: a note explaining why you think the source is unreliable as per WP:RS. Displays as a tool tip. Keep it short (one sentence) as longer material belongs on the talk page. It is good to reiterate the reason in your edit summary. Example:
{{Unreliable source?|reason=Your WP:RS-based reason here.|date=November 2024}} - sure or certain: if set to "y" or "yes" will remove the question mark from the template's output to denote a degree of certainty that the source is unreliable. Please use this with a
|reason=parameter, and only after a good faith attempt to verify the reliability of the source in question. Example:{{Unreliable source?|sure=y|reason=Your WP:RS-based reason here.|date=November 2024}}NOTE: This parameter has an alias,|failed=, which may make more grammatical sense when used with certain redirects like{{verify credibility}}.
When to use and not use this template
This template should be used to express your doubt about the credibility of a source.
This tag should not be used on unreliably sourced contentious statements about living persons; if a source for such a statement is not reliable, the statement and the source should be removed immediately.
For whole articles or article sections that rely on suspect sources, considering using the banner template {{More citations needed}} or {{More citations needed section}}, respectively, rather than individually tagging a large number of statements.
For sources promoting fringe theories and pseudo-science, the more specific template {{Unreliable fringe source}} can be used. Even more specifically, flag improperly sourced medical claims with {{Unreliable medical source}}.
This tag should not be used to indicate that the sourced material could not be found within a given source. In that case, {{failed verification}} is a better template. For statements that have failed verification and have a questionable would-be source, consider removal of the source (and possibly the statement) over using both tags.
TemplateData
This is the TemplateData documentation for this template used by VisualEditor and other tools.
Unreliable source?
Used when a statement is sourced but it is questionable whether the source used is reliable for supporting the statement.
| Parameter | Description | Type | Status | |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Reason | reason | Note explaining why you think the source is unreliable as per WP:RS. Displays as a tool tip | String | optional |
| Certain? | certain sure failed | If set to "y" or "yes" will remove the question mark from the template's output to denote a degree of certainty that the source is unreliable
| Boolean | optional |
| Month and year | date | Month and year of tagging; e.g., 'January 2013', but not 'jan13'
| String | suggested |
| name | name | no description | String | optional |
Redirects
The following may presently be used as shortcuts and aliases for this template:
- {{Reliable source}}
- {{rs}}
- {{rs?}}
- {{Unreliable source}}
- {{Unreliable source inline}}
- {{vc}}
- {{Verify credibility}}
See also
Inline templates
{{Better source needed}}, an alternative to{{Unreliable source?|certain=y}}; especially useful for tagging sources that are low-quality but not necessarily wrong{{Dubious}}, for questionable claims that seem unlikely to be properly sourceable{{Obsolete source}}, for when a source has been surpassed by more recent works{{Primary source inline}}, for misuse of primary source material{{Unreliable fringe source}}, for fringe sources{{Unreliable medical source}}, for fringe medical sources in particular
Lists of templates
- Wikipedia:Template index/Cleanup/Verifiability and sources
- Wikipedia:Template index/Sources of articles
Policies, guidelines, essays, and WikiProjects
- Wikipedia:Citing sources, especially § Unsourced material
- Wikipedia:Independent sources
- Wikipedia:Reliable sources
- Wikipedia:Verifiability
- Wikipedia:WikiProject Reliability
